Recent critic reviews for *Practical Magic 2*, which lifted embargo on September 8 ahead of its September 10 theatrical release, have settled the Tomatometer in the low-to-mid 30s based on roughly 60 reviews—slightly above the 1998 original’s 30%. Critics cite a wonky script, lack of fresh magic, and uneven tone as primary drags, while crediting Susanne Bier’s direction and the enduring chemistry between Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman for any redeeming warmth. Nostalgia and strong tracking for a $30–40 million opening weekend suggest audience scores could diverge sharply once verified ratings arrive, mirroring the first film’s cult appeal despite poor critical consensus. The score remains fluid with additional reviews expected in the coming days.